Publication View

Sex, Science and Educational Research: the unholy trinity (2006)

Abstract
This article examines the state's contemporary construction of 'sex' as an educational problem in England. It does so by interrogating the notion of the 'pregnant teenager' as it is semantically and statistically constructed in accountability discourses, as well as research constrained within them. It then examines certain features of an exemplary solution to the problem, as proferred by one of the largest contemporary research projects into sex education in the UK (the RIPPLE project). A critique is offered of the 'scientific' nature of some of these findings. We claim conclusions to be undermined by statistical and rhetorical gerrymandering, a prejudicial rendering of pupil 'voice', and an underlying reductionism. The article concludes that many of the features of such current problem-constructing and solution-rendering can be characterised as a false invocation of 'Science', and that their conjunction fuels an enduring infantilisation of educational discourses about sex and sex education.

Publication details
Download http://hdl.handle.net/2173/1834
Publisher Manchester Metropolitan University
Repository e-space at MMU (United Kingdom)
Type Preprint

Cited publications (3)
M. DOUGLAS, Purity and Danger. An Analysis of the Concepts of Pollution and Taboo
Effect of social exclusion on the risk of teenage pregnancy: development of hypotheses using baseline data from a randomised trial of sex education (2003)
  • Bonell,
  • C.P.,
  • Strange,
  • V.J.,
  • Stephenson,
  • J.M.,
  • Oakley,
  • A.R.,
  • Copas,
  • A.J.,
  • Forrest,
  • S.P.,
  • Johnson,
  • A.M.,
  • Black,
  • S.
Making sex: body and gender from the Greeks to Freud